More from the debate about climate change data

More from the debate about climate change data

For what it’s worth, Guy McPherson is making a new prediction based on…..?  I do know of what person who could make that prediction based on daily observations – Margo. 

I don’t accept everything I am told these days, but tend to ask questions.

In the meantime more material comes out that throws doubt on commonly-accepted data.

IPCC adjusts temperature data to create the impression of catastrophic global warming

One of the claims the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (“IPCC”) makes in their August 2021 report is that “urbanisation bias” is very small, less than 10%.  Dr. Willie Soon says this is nonsense. It’s at least 40% and it’s easy to prove.

“The way they [IPCC] approach science – everything is not science, everything is cartoon science.  They turn everything into a cartoon … all of it is not even close to the truth, it’s a joke” Dr. Soon said.

Dr. Soon, an astrophysicist and geoscientist and co-team leader at CERES Science, is a leading authority on the relationship between solar phenomena and global climate.  For more than 32 years he has been studying the Sun-Earth relations in terms of not only meteorology and climate, but also in terms of orbital dynamics of Sun-Earth-other planets interactions, magmatic (volcanoes) and tectonic (earthquakes) activities.

During the Heartland Institute’s 15th International Conference on Climate Change (“ICCC15”) in February, Dr. Soon used data from rural temperature stations to avoid urban heat island contamination of the temperature data and considered whether solar activity can explain global warming at rural stations. As his Heartland Institute talk was limited to 20 minutes, he met with Tom Nelson a week later to go through his presentation more thoroughly. You can find the slides for his presentation HERE.

Between the 1930s and the 1940s Joseph Kincer noted that temperatures had been increasing worldwide for decades.   During the 1940s and the 1970s Kincer noted that the warming had stopped and was reversing. Others confirmed the global cooling.  How was this possible? “It’s basically how they adjusted the data, it’s the homogenisation problem,” Dr. Soon said.

In the 1980s global warming returned. One of the early promoters of catastrophic global warming was Dr. James Hansen who gave testimony in 1988 in the US Senate. The world panicked and the IPCC was formed.  “This was a political move, obviously.  The evidence he had was very weak.” Dr. Soon said.  After this, narratives were created to stop those challenging the IPCC’s position from interfering with the UN goals.

The problem with IPCC temperature data, Dr. Soon explained, is that they combine urban and rural stations and only use homogenised data.  At the various stations collecting data, there could be non-climatic biases.  For example, a tree has grown that shades the instruments collecting temperature data.  Another example is the urban heat island effect.  Cities are warmer than the surrounding countryside.  If many buildings have sprung up around instruments collecting temperature data, this increases the recorded temperature significantly. Other non-climatic biases include changes in instrumentation, a station moves, cutting down of nearby trees or shrubs and changes in land use.

By taking rural temperature data only, Dr. Soon demonstrates how the trends shown are supported by trends shown in sea surface temperatures, tree rings and glacial length records.  This in turn proves that the upwards trend in global temperature as shown by IPCC is contaminated by urbanisation bias and urban blending. He also discussed the difficulties of measuring light intensity from the Sun and having overcome these, how data representing solar activity correlated to the temperature data from rural stations.

You can watch Dr. Soon’s full presentation below.

Dr. Willie Soon, an astrophysicist and geoscientist, is a leading authority on the relationship between solar phenomena and global climate. In this 32+ years of singular pursuit, he seeks to understand the Sun-Earth relations in terms of not only meteorology and climate, but also in terms of orbital dynamics of Sun-Earth-other planets interactions, magmatic (volcanoes) and tectonic (earthquakes) activities. His discoveries challenge computer modelers and advocates who consistently underestimate solar influences on cloud formation, ocean currents, and wind that cause climate to change. He has faced and risen above unethical and often libelous attacks on his research and his character, becoming one of the world’s most respected and influential voices for climate realism. In 2018, he founded the Center for Environmental Research and Earth Sciences ( in order to tackle a wider range of issues and topics without fears nor prejudices. Dr. Soon was an astrophysicist at the Solar, Stellar and Planetary Sciences Division of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, from 1991-2022. He served as receiving editor for New Astronomy from 2002-2016, astronomer at the Mount Wilson Observatory from 1992-2009. He is also on the editorial board of Geoscience, an MDPI publication since 2020 as well as serving as Review Editor of Frontiers in Earth Science starting 2022. Dr. Soon has also held the role of visiting professors at various institutions including University of Putra, Malaysia, Institute of Earth Environment of Xian, China and State Key Laboratory of Marine Environmental Science at Xiamen University. Since September 2021, Dr. Soon is also affiliated with Hungary’s Institute of Earth Physics and Space Science. Dr. Soon earned bachelor’s and master’s degrees in science and a Ph.D. in aerospace engineering from the University of Southern California. “The whole point of science is to question accepted dogmas.
For that reason, I respect Willie Soon as a good scientist and a courageous citizen.’’ — Freeman Dyson in the Boston Globe, November 5, 2013 Slides for this presentation:…
Here’s the Gavin Schmidt modeling talk mentioned by Willie:    • Challenges and fu…  
Willie mentioned his “Global Warming: Fact or Fiction?” talk that has almost 1 million views:    • Global Warming: F…  
About Willie’s April 2022 “Weaponization of Science…” Hillsdale College talk:…
Full Hillsdale College talk:
Chris Morrison: “Sixty seconds later, the temperature fell to 39.7°C”: Background on the question I asked around the 32-min mark:…
103 of his peer-reviewed papers:
“How much has the Sun influenced Northern Hemisphere temperature trends? An ongoing debate”:…
Tom Nelson: Willie Soon, Global warming: Mostly human-caused or natural? 8 March 2023 (79 mins)My ability to import tweets into the blog seems to have disappeared todayA PROBE INTO ALL BUREAU OF METEOROLOGY WEATHER RECORDS IN AUSTRALIA

Today in their Editorial, The Australian has called for a PROBE INTO ALL BUREAU OF METEOROLOGY WEATHER RECORDS after it was uncovered from an FOI request (that the BOM tried to fight in Court) that the BOM had been lying about the effect of equipment changes, hiding the fact that Australia’s temperatures records have being artificially heated. However, nine years ago Tony Abbott tried to conduct such as inquiry but he was undermined by Greg Hunt and others in his cabinet. Then he was rolled. So in the decade since, the BOM have acted not like a scientific organisation, but like a publicity agency for the Climate Alarmists pushing out fake news & propaganda – which contributed to a mass loss of Liberal seats to the Teals. Simply, the weak pathetic Liberals failed to stand up and fight when it was needed – appeasing the crocodile hoping to be eaten last. The Labor Government Minister with the currently responsible for the BOM is Tanya Plibersek – a signed up card-carrying climate cultist – and the chances of her conducting any sort of real investigation in the BOM’s malfeasance and cooking of the data is zero. And having failed to hold this inquiry into BOM when in office, the Liberals will get nowhere calling for one from opposition.

Listen 19m in HERE

This tends to support a hypothesis put forward by Ian Wishart.

Geothermal heat can accumulate in the deep ocean over time

I was unable to open THIS link on the computer but succeeded on the iPad!

Here’s Richard E Klein on a Tom Nelson podcast explaining his hypothesis that the earth’s ice ages are caused internally.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Wordpress Social Share Plugin powered by Ultimatelysocial